Skip to content
☀️ Heat advisory: creams & soaps may soften in transit — harmless, just let them cool before opening.
☀️ Heat advisory: creams & soaps may soften in transit — harmless, just let them cool before opening.

After Shave Balms

Discover the ultimate secret to achieving the perfect shave with our premium collection of post shave balms at New England Shaving. Whether you're looking to calm sensitive skin, prevent irritation, or maintain a healthy, refreshed complexion, our carefully selected balms offer the ideal finishing touch.

Our range includes everything from the time honored performance of brands like Castle Forbes and Proraso to the small batch craftsmanship of Wholly Kaw, Barrister and Mann, and Stirling Soap Co. Each brings something unique; whether it’s a classic formula passed down through generations or a modern blend built on innovative, skin focused bases.

Typically low or alcohol free, aftershave balms absorb quickly, reduce redness, and lock in moisture; leaving your skin smooth, balanced, and well cared for.

Explore our collection today and elevate your post shave routine to a moment of pure luxury.

Original price $61.00 - Original price $61.00
Original price
$61.00
$61.00 - $61.00
Current price $61.00

Castle Forbes - Cedarwood & Sandalwood After Shave Balm

Castle Forbes
In stock

Formulated for all skin types, this Cedarwood and Sandalwood Aftershave Balm is an exceptionally soothing option. It uses natural ingredients like ...

View full details
Original price $61.00 - Original price $61.00
Original price
$61.00
$61.00 - $61.00
Current price $61.00
Original price $61.00 - Original price $61.00
Original price
$61.00
$61.00 - $61.00
Current price $61.00

Castle Forbes - Lime After Shave Balm

Castle Forbes
In stock

Designed for sensitive skin and ideal for those prone to nicks and cuts, Castle Forbes Lime Aftershave Balm is fragranced only with essential oils ...

View full details
Original price $61.00 - Original price $61.00
Original price
$61.00
$61.00 - $61.00
Current price $61.00
Original price $61.00 - Original price $61.00
Original price
$61.00
$61.00 - $61.00
Current price $61.00

Castle Forbes - Lavender Essential Oil After Shave Balm

Castle Forbes
In stock

Lavender Essential Oil After Shave Balm is a soothing, alcohol free formula that uses natural witch hazel to close pores and moisturize the skin. I...

View full details
Original price $61.00 - Original price $61.00
Original price
$61.00
$61.00 - $61.00
Current price $61.00
Original price $61.00 - Original price $61.00
Original price
$61.00
$61.00 - $61.00
Current price $61.00

Castle Forbes - 1445 After Shave Balm

Castle Forbes
In stock

Ideal for sensitive skin and skin prone to nicks and cuts, Castle Forbes 1445 Aftershave Balm is fragranced only with essential oils and contains n...

View full details
Original price $61.00 - Original price $61.00
Original price
$61.00
$61.00 - $61.00
Current price $61.00
Original price $16.99 - Original price $16.99
Original price
$16.99
$16.99 - $16.99
Current price $16.99

Taconic Shave - Soothing After Shave Balm with Aloe Vera

Taconic Shave
In stock

Taconic Shave's After Shave Balm will leave your skin feeling soothed, cooled and moisturized; your skin will look and feel healthier. Packed with...

View full details
Original price $16.99 - Original price $16.99
Original price
$16.99
$16.99 - $16.99
Current price $16.99
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Unscented Post-Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
Out of stock

Unscented Aftershave Balm is a gentle and versatile option that pairs well with any fragrance or can be worn alone. Ideal for sensitive skin, it hy...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Bay Rum Post Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

This aftershave balm offers a refined interpretation of the classic Bay Rum aroma. Bay West Indies (Pimenta Racemosa) essential oil is blended with...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95

Stirling Soap Co. - Unscented Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Stirling Soap Co. Unscented Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner provides gentle, effective post-shave care without added fragrance or essentia...

View full details
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00

Henri Et Victoria - Cognac and Cuban Cigars After Shave Balm

Henri Et Victoria
In stock

Close your eyes, savor the smell, and let it linger for just a moment longer; you have arrived in Cuba. Imagine the pleasure of an afternoon game o...

View full details
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95

Stirling Soap Co. - Tea Tree Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Stirling Soap Co. Tea Tree Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner combines natural skin soothing ingredients with the cleansing power of pure Aus...

View full details
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95

Stirling Soap Co. - Bergamot Lavender Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Stirling Soap Co. Bergamot Lavender Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner delivers a smooth, refreshing finish after every shave. This alcohol f...

View full details
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95
Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
Original price
$44.00
$44.00 - $44.00
Current price $44.00

Geo. F. Trumper - Extract of Limes Skin Food

Geo. F. Trumper
In stock

Geo F. Trumper Extract of Limes Skin Food is a versatile addition to any grooming routine, suitable for both pre-shave and post-shave care. Its lig...

View full details
Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
Original price
$44.00
$44.00 - $44.00
Current price $44.00
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00

Henri Et Victoria - Unscented After Shave Balm

Henri Et Victoria
In stock

A daily essential, this soothing after shave balm delivers a powerful boost of hydration to the skin post-shave. It locks in essential moisture, le...

View full details
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00

Henri Et Victoria - Duc de Santal After Shave Balm

Henri Et Victoria
In stock

Duc de Santal invites you to sit back and savor the musky, woody aroma of refined masculinity. This warm, comforting scent speaks of sophistication...

View full details
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Bergamot Lavender Post Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

This aftershave balm captures the idea of lavender with a twist. Imagine if lavender had a peel: a bright, spicy, and lightly sweet aroma wrapped a...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Glacial Unscented Post-Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

An unscented option with enough menthol to freeze your face off. Pairs well with any scent. Great for those with sensitive skin who love a good chi...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Sharp Dressed Man Post-Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Sharp Dressed Man Aftershave Balm brings the iconic Green Irish Tweed-inspired scent to your post-shave routine. Crisp green notes blend with soft ...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
Original price
$44.00
$44.00 - $44.00
Current price $44.00

Geo. F. Trumper - Sandalwood Skin Food

Geo. F. Trumper
In stock

Geo F. Trumper Sandalwood Skin Food is a flexible grooming essential that can be used before or after shaving. Its light, non-oily glycerin base ab...

View full details
Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
Original price
$44.00
$44.00 - $44.00
Current price $44.00
Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
Original price
$44.00
$44.00 - $44.00
Current price $44.00

Geo. F. Trumper - Eucris Skin Food

Geo. F. Trumper
In stock

Geo F. Trumper Eucris Skin Food is a flexible grooming essential that works before or after shaving. Its lightweight, non-oily formula nourishes an...

View full details
Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
Original price
$44.00
$44.00 - $44.00
Current price $44.00
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00

Henri Et Victoria - Lime After Shave Balm

Henri Et Victoria
Low stock

The Henri et Victoria Lime Aftershave Balm delivers immediate relief and lasting hydration, soothing the skin and sealing in moisture after every s...

View full details
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95

Stirling Soap Co. - Unscented with Menthol Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Stirling Soap Co. Unscented with Menthol Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner offers a clean, cooling finish without added fragrance. This alco...

View full details
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Gentleman Post Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

This aftershave balm is made for the man whose presence speaks before he does. You hold doors without thinking twice. Polite words come naturally. ...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - D-503 Post Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
Out of stock

This aftershave balm features a bold, masculine fragrance inspired by Mont Blanc Legend. It opens with a bright mix of citrus and lavender, leading...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Deep Blue Sea Post Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
Out of stock

This aftershave balm delivers a fresh and modern blend inspired by Bleu de Chanel. The scent opens with bright citrus and soft mint, layered over e...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - I, Rich Moose Post Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
Low stock

This aftershave balm brings back a beloved classic scent many wet shavers still miss. While nothing can truly duplicate the original, this blend co...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00

Henri Et Victoria - Bay Rum After Shave Balm

Henri Et Victoria
In stock

Henri et Victoria Bay Rum After Shave Balm offers classic post shave care with a warm and spicy fragrance. It hydrates the skin while helping reduc...

View full details
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00

Henri Et Victoria - Navigateur After Shave Balm

Henri Et Victoria
In stock

Henri et Victoria Navigateur After Shave Balm delivers deep hydration and post shave comfort with a smooth, non greasy finish. It helps calm irrita...

View full details
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95

Stirling Soap Co. - Glacial Wintergreen Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Glacial Wintergreen delivers an intensely cold, invigorating post-shave experience paired with a crisp wintergreen scent. Bright, minty, and refres...

View full details
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95

Stirling Soap Co. - Electric Sheep Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Stirling Soap Co. Electric Sheep Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner delivers an energizing finish with a bright, clean scent that wakes up yo...

View full details
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Sandpiper Post-Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Sandpiper Post-Shave Balm features a crisp, sophisticated scent built on cardamom top notes, a heart of bergamot, cedar, and lavender, and base not...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00

Henri Et Victoria - Costa After Shave Balm

Henri Et Victoria
In stock

Henri et Victoria Costa After Shave Balm provides lasting hydration and comfort after shaving. Its lightweight formula absorbs easily, leaving skin...

View full details
Original price $23.00 - Original price $23.00
Original price
$23.00
$23.00 - $23.00
Current price $23.00
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Scots Pine Post-Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Enjoy a calm and refreshing finish to your shave with this thoughtfully crafted aftershave balm. The scent offers a smooth, natural pine aroma bala...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Ozark Mountain Post Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

This aftershave balm captures the feeling of an autumn drive through the Ozark Mountains. Its aroma is woodsy, warm, and lightly spicy, offering th...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Margaritas in the Arctic Post-Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Margaritas in the Arctic aftershave balm delivers a refreshing blend of bright citrus and icy menthol for a cooling post-shave experience. The scen...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95

Stirling Soap Co. - Orange Chill Witch Hazel & Aloe

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Orange Chill delivers a bright burst of citrus with a refreshing menthol twist. The scent captures the essence of sweet, freshly peeled orange pair...

View full details
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95

Stirling Soap Co. - Margaritas in the Arctic After Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

Stirling Soap Co. Margaritas in the Arctic Witch Hazel & Aloe After Shave Toner delivers an invigorating blast of cool refreshment that feels l...

View full details
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Stirling Soap Co. - Black Post Shave Balm

Stirling Soap Co.
In stock

This aftershave balm brings together a tropical and woodsy mix inspired by Polo Black. Iced mango meets silver armoise, sandalwood, and patchouli, ...

View full details
Original price $10.60 - Original price $10.60
Original price
$10.60
$10.60 - $10.60
Current price $10.60

Why Aftershave Balm Deserves a Place in Your Shaving Routine

Aftershave balm plays a critical role in post-shave skin care. Shaving doesn’t just remove hair, it temporarily compromises the skin barrier, increases moisture loss, and leaves skin vulnerable to irritation. A properly formulated balm helps counteract these effects by calming the skin, restoring hydration, and supporting recovery without the sting often associated with traditional alcohol-based aftershaves.

Unlike splashes or colognes, aftershave balm focuses on skin health first, making it suitable for daily use and for all areas of the body where shaving causes stress.

How Aftershave Balm Supports Post-Shave Skin

Freshly shaved skin is often warm, sensitive, and slightly inflamed. A good aftershave balm addresses this immediately by reducing redness and discomfort while replenishing lost moisture.

Hydration is a key part of this process, but it’s not just about adding moisture, it’s about keeping it in the skin. Well-balanced balms create a breathable protective layer that limits water loss without clogging pores or feeling greasy. At the same time, barrier-supporting ingredients help skin return to normal more quickly, reducing the likelihood of razor burn, ingrown hairs, and post-shave tightness.

This makes balm especially useful for frequent shavers, sensitive skin types, and anyone shaving coarse or curly hair.

Aftershave Balm vs Traditional Moisturizer

Although moisturizers hydrate the skin, most are not designed for the immediate aftermath of shaving. They often lack the soothing and anti-inflammatory components needed to calm freshly shaved skin.

Aftershave balm is formulated specifically to manage post-shave stress. It prioritizes comfort, recovery, and barrier repair before general hydration. Moisturizer can still play a role later in the routine, but balm is the product designed for the moment right after the razor.

Skin Types That Benefit Most

Aftershave balm is effective across all skin types, but certain users see especially strong results:

  • Sensitive skin benefits from reduced redness, burning, and reactivity
  • Dry skin gains immediate comfort and lasting hydration
  • Oily or acne-prone skin benefits from lightweight, non-comedogenic formulas that calm inflammation without clogging pores
  • Coarse or curly hair types see fewer ingrown hairs and razor bumps due to improved skin condition

Environmental factors such as cold weather, dry air, or air-conditioned spaces can also increase moisture loss, making balm even more valuable.

Ingredients That Define a High-Quality Aftershave Balm

The best aftershave balms are built around proven, skin-supportive ingredients rather than fillers or heavy fragrance. Many respected grooming brands share common ingredient philosophies focused on soothing, hydration, and barrier health.

Soothing & Anti-Irritation Ingredients

  • Aloe Vera – Widely used for its cooling and calming properties
  • Allantoin – Helps reduce redness and supports skin repair
  • Oat Extract or Oat Protein – Calms irritation and improves skin comfort, especially for sensitive skin

Hydration & Moisture Retention

  • Glycerin – A classic humectant that draws moisture into the skin
  • Saccharide Isomerate – A long-lasting hydrator that binds water to the skin
  • Hyaluronic Acid – Provides lightweight hydration without heaviness

Barrier & Skin Conditioning Oils

  • Squalane (Olive-Derived) – Mimics the skin’s natural oils and absorbs quickly
  • Jojoba Oil – Helps regulate oil production and maintain balance
  • Castor Oil – Softens skin and supports recovery when used in balanced amounts

Butters & Emollients

  • Shea Butter – Nourishes and protects without clogging pores when properly formulated
  • Kokum Butter – Rich yet lightweight, offering softness without greasiness
  • Cupuacu Butter – Known for its moisture-retention properties

Botanical & Specialty Additions

  • Calendula – Supports healing and reduces sensitivity
  • Chamomile – Helps calm reactive skin
  • Radish Seed Oil – Lightweight, fast-absorbing, and texture-enhancing

These ingredients are commonly found across premium aftershave balms because they work; not because they sound impressive.

What to Look for in a Well-Made Aftershave Balm

A good aftershave balm should feel effortless to use. It should spread easily, absorb quickly, and leave skin feeling comfortable rather than coated. Heavy residue, excessive shine, or lingering stickiness are signs of poor formulation.

Scent should be subtle and supportive, never overpowering. Whether fragranced or unscented, the focus should remain on skin performance, not masking irritation with fragrance.

Aftershave balm is one of the most effective ways to improve how your skin feels after shaving. It reduces irritation, restores hydration, and supports long-term skin health, benefits that extend far beyond the moment you finish shaving.

Whether you shave daily or occasionally, use a cartridge or a safety razor, or shave your face or body, a properly formulated aftershave balm helps your skin recover faster and stay healthier over time.

Choosing a balm with thoughtful ingredients and a balanced formula isn’t about luxury, it’s about using a product that actually does what post-shave skin needs.