Skip to content

All After Shaves Products

Discover our range of after shave treatments including after shave balms, lotions and creams. Our comprehensive selection of after shave products will sooth and moisturize your skin to keep it in good condition. Choose from our broad range of brands to add a touch of luxury to your shaving experience.

After completing your shaving ritual, it's essential to provide your skin with the care it deserves. Our collection of aftershaves goes beyond mere post-shave hydration. Each product is formulated to address specific skin concerns, from soothing irritation to replenishing moisture.

Our after-shave balms offer an effective solution for calming sensitive skin, reducing redness, and preventing discomfort. For those seeking a refreshing and invigorating experience, our after-shave lotions provide an instant burst of hydration and revitalization.

If you prefer a richer, more indulgent option, our after-shave creams deliver deep hydration and intensive nourishment. Choose from our broad range of brands to find the perfect aftershave option for you whether it’s balm, location or cream. Elevate your grooming routine to keep your skin looking and feeling its best, day after day.

Filters

  • Original price $23.95 - Original price $23.95
    Original price
    $23.95
    $23.95 - $23.95
    Current price $23.95

    Captain's Choice - Bay Rum Aftershave

    Captain's Choice

    The one that started it all. This was the first release from Captain's Choice back in the beginning. Our Bay Rum aftershave delivers an authentic s...

    View full details
    Original price $23.95 - Original price $23.95
    Original price
    $23.95
    $23.95 - $23.95
    Current price $23.95
  • Original price $23.95 - Original price $23.95
    Original price
    $23.95
    $23.95 - $23.95
    Current price $23.95

    Captain's Choice - Venture Aftershave

    Captain's Choice

    Go forth inspired by the joy that is Venture. Celebrate success with a well-balanced aroma that is sure to become a favorite.  A cheerful surge of ...

    View full details
    Original price $23.95 - Original price $23.95
    Original price
    $23.95
    $23.95 - $23.95
    Current price $23.95
  • Original price $23.95 - Original price $23.95
    Original price
    $23.95
    $23.95 - $23.95
    Current price $23.95

    Captain's Choice - Lime Aftershave

    Captain's Choice

    A crisp, subtle fragrance that will rejuvenate your mornings.  Now you can look forward to the subtle aroma of a truly natural lime scent each morn...

    View full details
    Original price $23.95 - Original price $23.95
    Original price
    $23.95
    $23.95 - $23.95
    Current price $23.95
  • Original price $23.95 - Original price $23.95
    Original price
    $23.95
    $23.95 - $23.95
    Current price $23.95

    Captain's Choice - Cat O' Nine Tails Aftershave

    Captain's Choice

    A bay rum for those who want more zest to the experience! Created to answer the need for a more bracing experience, Cat O' Nine Tails delivers!   I...

    View full details
    Original price $23.95 - Original price $23.95
    Original price
    $23.95
    $23.95 - $23.95
    Current price $23.95
  • Original price $23.95 - Original price $23.95
    Original price
    $23.95
    $23.95 - $23.95
    Current price $23.95

    Captain's Choice - 45th Parallel Aftershave

    Captain's Choice

    A terrific almond / cherry blend that has customers raving! Whoever said that an aftershave can’t smell simply luscious? We present a magical blend...

    View full details
    Original price $23.95 - Original price $23.95
    Original price
    $23.95
    $23.95 - $23.95
    Current price $23.95

FAQ’s

What are the differences between alcohol-based and non-alcoholic aftershaves, and what are the pros and cons of each?

Alcohol-based aftershaves have been a staple for many years, offering several benefits:

  • Efficient Disinfection: Alcohol is effective at killing bacteria, which was crucial in barbershops where blades were shared among customers.
  • Invigorating Sensation: The tingling feeling from alcohol can leave you feeling refreshed and alert.
  • Pore Closure: Alcohol helps close pores, which can provide a smooth finish.

However, alcohol-based aftershaves may not be ideal for everyone. They can dry out the skin and potentially cause ingrown hairs by closing pores. In colder months, this drying effect might be more pronounced.

On the other hand, non-alcoholic or low-alcohol aftershaves are perfect for those with sensitive skin or skin prone to dryness. These products focus on moisturizing and soothing without compromising on hygiene.

What are the benefits of using a balm over a splash or lotion?

Aftershaves come in three main forms, each catering to different skin types and preferences:

Splashes:

  • Usually high in alcohol content
  • Provide a strong disinfecting effect
  • Can be invigorating but potentially harsh on skin
  • Often scented

Lotions:

  • Slightly thicker consistency than splashes
  • May contain alcohol, but often in lower concentrations
  • Can offer more soothing properties than splashes
  • Available in various scents

Balms:

  • Most popular for their soothing and moisturizing qualities
  • Typically low in alcohol or alcohol-free
  • Use alternative antiseptic ingredients
  • Help keep pores open for healthy hair growth
  • Often contain natural ingredients like essential oils
  • Available in scented and unscented options

When choosing an aftershave, consider your skin type, personal preferences, and the season. For example, a moisturizing balm might be ideal for dry winter months, while a refreshing splash could be perfect for hot summer days.

Remember, the right aftershave can transform your shaving routine from a chore into a luxurious self-care ritual. Experiment with different types to find the one that leaves your skin feeling its best.