Skip to content

Soft Shaving Soaps

Shaving soaps are an essential part of a classic shaving routine, providing the perfect foundation for a smooth, irritation-free shave. When lathered well with a shaving brush, usually for 30 seconds to a minute, the soap transforms into a rich, creamy foam that softens the skin and ensures optimal lubrication between the razor blade and your skin. This thick lather also helps to thoroughly cleanse the skin while reducing friction, preventing post-shave irritation.

Many shaving soaps are made with tallow-based formulas, which create a quick-acting foam that hydrates the skin and makes lathering easier, even in hard water. For those with sensitive skin, there are 100% vegetable-based options that are free from parabens and harsh alcohols, enriched with natural ingredients that nourish, protect, and hydrate the skin. Italian-made soaps are particularly renowned for their soft, creamy consistency, making it simple to whip up a luxurious, thick lather that enhances your shaving experience. Whether tallow-based or plant-based, shaving soaps deliver both performance and skin care, offering a refreshing and indulgent shave every time.

Soft shaving soaps use a natural method, and it is quite normal for soaps to have irregular cavity structures and for their surfaces to not be completely smooth. This does not affect the quality of the soap and should not be considered a flaw.

  • Ariana and Evans Chasing the Dragon Shaving Soap
    Original price $24.95 - Original price $24.95
    Original price
    $24.95
    $24.95 - $24.95
    Current price $24.95

    Ariana & Evans -Chasing the Dragon Shaving Soap, Ultima Base

    Ariana Evans

    Chasing the Dragon is crafted with expertise, maintains a mysterious quality that can be worn both day and night.  The scent adds sophistication wi...

    View full details
    Original price $24.95 - Original price $24.95
    Original price
    $24.95
    $24.95 - $24.95
    Current price $24.95
  • Extro - 17 Stormo Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - 17 Stormo Shaving Cream

    3 reviews Extro

    The 17 Stormo Shaving Cream is a fragrance of pure instinct, an alchemy of eroticism and mystery, an expression of positive emotions. An endless ad...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - 2/11 Duenovember Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - 2/11 Duenovember Shaving Cream

    Extro

    The shaving cream is specially crafted without the use of essences. Instead, the captivating fragrance is derived solely from the essential oils of...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Absinthium Artemisia Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Absinthium Artemisia Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Wormwood is a plant scientifically called Artemisia Absinthium. It is a rather common shrub in the alpine areas, characterized by a silvery green c...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Arancia Italiana Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Arancia Italiana Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Embrace the invigorating fragrance of citrus and red fruits, a symphony of freshness that uplifts your senses during your grooming routine. Enriche...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Arzachena Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Extro - Arzachena Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Arzachena Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Immerse yourself in the essence of Arzachena, where the vibrant green of chlorophyll extract meets the ocean breeze, elegantly blending with the en...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Barocco Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Barocco Shaving Cream

    Extro

    The Baroque shaving cream, also lovingly known as the "Herb of Grace," draws its essence from the revered Bacopa monnieri. This exceptional plant e...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Bay Rum Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Bay Rum Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Bay Shaving Cream, thoughtfully enriched with Coenzyme Q10, renowned for its potent anti-wrinkle properties, and elastin, a protein that keeps your...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Caffe Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Caffe Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Experience the epitome of indulgence with this exquisite shaving cream, thoughtfully crafted to elevate your grooming routine to new heights. Enric...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Camelot Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Extro - Camelot Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Camelot Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Enriched with the nurturing properties of Neem oil, Camelot Shaving cream ensures a delightful and soothing shaving experience. Head: Patchouli, Be...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Dandy Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Dandy Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Immerse yourself in the essence of refinement with Extro Dandy Shaving Cream, thoughtfully enriched with the luxurious benefits of argan oil. Exper...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - del Don Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Extro - del Don Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - del Don Shaving Cream

    Extro

    The del Don Shaving Cream is a true classic with woody and citrusy aromas and with notes of petit grain, basil, lavender, sage and thyme all mingle...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Egyptian Oudh Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Immerse yourself in the world of refined grooming with Extro Egyptian Oudh Shaving Cream. Crafted with a blend reminiscent of the beloved Espezial,...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Espezial Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Espezial Shaving Cream

    Extro

    This luxurious shaving cream is thoughtfully enriched with potent ingredients: Coenzyme Q10, renowned for its anti-wrinkle properties, working dili...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Felce Bianco Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Felce Biancospino Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Experience the art of sophistication with every shave, as the delicate combination of hawthorn and fern transports you to an exclusive world of ele...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - FraRinik Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - FraRinik Shaving Cream

    1 Review Extro

    The FraRinik Shaving Cream is also known as Fragranza Mistica, which translates as Mystical Scent, and it is one of the jewels in the Extro line. F...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Freddo Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Sold out
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Freddo Shaving Cream

    Extro

    The Freddo Shaving Cream is named after the Italian word for cold. This shaving cream gives a great ‘wake me up’ shave in the morning with its cool...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
    Sold out
  • Extro - Hammamilla Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Hamamilla Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Indulge in the essence of pure botanical care with our shaving cream, meticulously crafted with the finest ingredients. Enriched with hamamelis ext...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Il Conte Di Puglia Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Il Conte Di Puglia Shaving Cream

    Extro

    The Il Conte di Puglia Shaving Cream with a base enriched with donkey milk, fenugreek, and extra virgin olive oil in honor of the region of Apulia....

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Isola Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Isola Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Step into the realm of supreme shaving luxury with newly improved Isola Shaving Cream, now enriched with the soothing essence of aloe extract. Disc...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Latte Mandorla Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Latte Mandorla Almond Milk Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Envisioned with the image of a donkey, Extro Almond Milk Shaving Cream celebrates the precious ingredient that sets it apart. Donkey's mil...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Lavanda Muschio Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Lavanda Muschio Shaving Cream

    Extro

    The Lavanda Muschio Shaving Cream is enriched with added shea butter and made with a hypoallergenic formula suitable for delicate and sensitive ski...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Legno Rosa Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Legno Di Rosa Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Indulge in the essence of luxury with Extro Rosewood Shaving Cream, meticulously crafted with the finest ingredients. Embrace the gentle touch of d...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Legno Di Sandalo Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Legno Di Sandalo Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Crafted with delicate skin in mind, Extro Sandalwood Shaving Cream embraces the essence of Icelandic lichens, working tirelessly to combat redness ...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Liquirizia & Magnolia Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Liquirizia & Magnolia Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Immerse in the delicate intensity of Amarelli licorice and enchanting magnolia flower. Amarelli is one of the Italian excellences, producing licori...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Miele Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Miele Shaving Cream

    2 Reviews Extro

    The Miele Shaving Cream is enriched with honey and is the perfect shaving cream to use during the cold winter weather. It has the most appealing to...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - O'Selvaggio Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - O' Selvaggio Shaving Cream

    Extro

    The Extro O' Selvaggio Shaving Cream with Jojoba Oil is a premium, handmade shaving cream formulated to provide a luxurious and smooth shaving expe...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Piemont Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Piemont Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Enriched with the nourishing goodness of Goat's Milk and Hazelnut oil, this shaving cream pampers your skin with an unmatched level of care. Absolu...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Extro - Pirata Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Sold out
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Pirata Shaving Cream

    2 Reviews Extro

    The Pirata Shaving Cream is a classic barbershop fragrance: Sicilian lemon, Tunisian rosemary, Calabrian bergamot, Egyptian jasmine, Sri Lankan cin...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
    Sold out
  • Extro - Positano Shaving Cream - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90

    Extro - Positano Shaving Cream

    Extro

    Experience the warmth of newly opened figs, delicately enriched with the nourishing essence of hypericum extract. This extract from St. John's wort...

    View full details
    Original price $27.90 - Original price $27.90
    Original price
    $27.90
    $27.90 - $27.90
    Current price $27.90
  • Officina Artigiana Milano - 5 Wellness Oils Shaving Soap - New England Shaving Company
    Officina Artigiana Milano - 5 Wellness Oils Shaving Soap - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $24.99 - Original price $24.99
    Original price
    $24.99
    $24.99 - $24.99
    Current price $24.99

    Officina Artigiana Milano - 5 Wellness Oils Shaving Soap

    4 Reviews Officina Artigiana Milano

    Natural and traditional shaving soap mainly made of 5 precious wellness oils of an Artisan workshop (Jojoba, Argan, Almond, Grapeseed and Castor). ...

    View full details
    Original price $24.99 - Original price $24.99
    Original price
    $24.99
    $24.99 - $24.99
    Current price $24.99
  • Officina Artigiana Milano - Maremoto Shaving Soap - New England Shaving Company
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $24.99
    $24.99 - $24.99
    Current price $24.99

    Officina Artigiana Milano - Maremoto Shaving Soap

    Officina Artigiana Milano

    Maremoto is sublime, innovative and refined, a fragrance that falls into the aromatic-aquatic type of fragrance group but is capable of going much ...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $24.99
    $24.99 - $24.99
    Current price $24.99
  • Officina Artigiana Milano - Stay Traditional Shaving Soap - New England Shaving Company
    Officina Artigiana Milano - Stay Traditional Shaving Soap - New England Shaving Company
    Sold out
    Original price $24.99 - Original price $24.99
    Original price
    $24.99
    $24.99 - $24.99
    Current price $24.99

    Officina Artigiana Milano - Stay Traditional Shaving Soap

    3 Reviews Officina Artigiana Milano

    Natural and traditional shaving soap mainly made of 5 precious wellness oils of an Artisan workshop (Jojoba, Argan, Almond, Grapeseed and Castor). ...

    View full details
    Original price $24.99 - Original price $24.99
    Original price
    $24.99
    $24.99 - $24.99
    Current price $24.99
    Sold out

How Are Soft Shaving Soaps Made?

Hot-Pour Soaps: Commonly used by artisans, this method creates soft, pliable soaps with dense, luxurious lathers. Proraso Shaving Soaps in tubs and Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Creams are great hot-pour soaps & creams.

Italian Saponification: A traditional process yielding smooth and creamy soaps for a premium shaving experience. Officina Artigiana Milano stands out as an example of a shaving soap made using the Italian hot saponification method.

Triple-Milled Soaps: Softer than traditional hard soaps but denser, products like Martin de Candre or Henri et Victoria offer long-lasting, refined lathers. Martin de Candre shaving soaps are also manufactured by a hot saponification process.

What Makes Tallow-Based Shaving Soaps Stand Out?

Tallow-based soaps are celebrated for their rich, creamy lather, exceptional slickness, and superior post-shave feel. Many top brands offer tallow-based formulations, including Cella Milano, Fine Accoutrements, Le Pere Lucien, Ariana & Evans, Barrister & Mann, Henri et Victoria, and Zingari Man.

Barrister & Mann – Omnibus Base:
Omnibus is a lanolin-free tallow base enriched with botanicals, goat and coconut milks, shea butter, avocado oil, and cupuaçu butter—a remarkable ingredient that absorbs up to 250% more water than lanolin without causing irritation. This base provides exceptional hydration and performance for a comfortable, irritation-free shave.

Ariana & Evans – Ultima Base:
Ultima represents the luxury line from Ariana & Evans. It excels in moisture retention, delivering unmatched slickness and a dense, luxurious lather. Known for its superior cushioning and protection, Ultima leaves the skin feeling nourished and pampered after every shave.

Ariana & Evans – K2E (Kaizen 2E) Base:
K2E takes tallow-based shaving soaps to the next level with a formula that offers extraordinary slickness, thickness, and hydration. Infused with kokum butter, shea butter, avocado oil, and emu oil, it ensures a smooth and moisturized shave, combining premium quality with excellent value.

These innovative bases showcase the versatility and performance of tallow-based soaps, making them a favorite among wet shaving enthusiasts seeking a luxurious and effective grooming experience.

What Scents Are Available?

Artisan soft shaving soaps are celebrated for their diverse scent profiles. Options range from classic barbershop aromas to complex blends of florals, spices, and woods. Seasonal or limited-edition scents bring uniqueness and variety, appealing to enthusiasts looking for exclusive fragrances. You can use our "Scent Profile" filter to help guide you toward your desired fragrance. Be sure to check each product's description for a complete breakdown of its fragrance notes.

Shaving with Acne-Prone Skin: What Should You Know?

Shaving with acne-prone skin requires extra care to avoid irritation and breakouts. To minimize the risk, it’s important to use gentle, non-comedogenic shaving products that are specifically formulated for acne-prone skin. Look for shaving creams or soaps that contain soothing and anti-inflammatory ingredients, such as aloe vera, tea tree oil, or salicylic acid, which can help calm the skin and prevent further breakouts. Always shave with a light touch, use a sharp razor to avoid tugging, and follow up with an alcohol-free, soothing aftershave to keep skin hydrated and protected.

Check out the Krokos Line from Abbate y La Mantia for a premium, acne-friendly shaving solution.

What are the best lathering shaving soaps from U.S. brands?

Check out the shaving soaps from Stirling Soap Co. and Zingari Man for a great lathering experience.

  1. Stirling Soap Co. – Known for its rich, dense lather, Stirling soaps offer excellent performance with skin-friendly ingredients. They create a creamy, slick lather that provides great glide and protection during shaving. Stirling also offers a wide range of scents, making it a popular choice among wet shaving enthusiasts.
  2. Zingari ManZingari Man takes a more artisanal approach to shaving soaps, with a focus on skin-nourishing ingredients like shea butter, lanolin, and coconut milk. These create a thick, moisturizing lather that provides exceptional glide and leaves the skin feeling hydrated and soft after shaving. The Gent scent is a sophisticated blend that is perfect for those looking for a refined, subtle fragrance.

How Do Prices Compare?

Soft shaving soaps range in price depending on the ingredients and craftsmanship. Artisan soaps, often made in small batches, may have a higher price point but deliver exceptional value through their performance, longevity, and luxurious experience.

Whether you prefer the richness of tallow, the innovation of vegan formulations, or the hydration of glycerin-based soaps, artisan soft shaving soaps provide an unmatched grooming experience. Explore these hand-crafted creations to elevate your shave.