Skip to content
Dark bay rum aftershave in 4 oz amber glass bottle with bold scent and intense warming feel for men who like strong, spicy splashes

Captain's Choice - Cat O' Nine Tails Aftershave

by Captain's Choice
$23.95 - $23.95
$23.95
$23.95 - $23.95
$23.95

A bay rum for those who want more zest in their experience!

Cat O’ Nine Tails was created for those who crave a bolder, more bracing aftershave. It may belong to the bay rum family, but it packs an unmistakable punch. Upon application to a freshly shaved face, this aftershave delivers a slow-building heat that culminates in a memorable warming sensation. This is bay rum extreme. Made for the man who can handle anything: if you want it, you know it, and you NEED it. Get ready to feel that BURN!

The name has roots in naval history: by the 17th century, the “cat o’ nine tails” was a rope whip used to discipline sailors. It’s also the origin of the phrase “Let the cat out of the bag”, a phrase no sailor ever wanted to hear.

  • Fragrance: Bold, spicy, dark bay rum with intense warmth
  • Experience: Strong warming effect on application
  • Bottle: 4 oz amber glass to preserve potency
  • Ingredients: Alcohol, witch hazel, essential oils & extracts, glycerin
  • Handcrafted in the USA

At New England Shaving, orders are processed same-day or within 1-2 business days. Weekend or holiday orders are processed the next business day.

Shipping Address: Ensure your shipping address is accurate and complete at checkout. We are not responsible for delays, losses, or undeliverable packages caused by incorrect information. Missing, lost, or stolen packages after delivery is completed to the provided shipping address are not the responsibility of the company and will not be refunded or replaced.

Shipping costs are calculated at checkout. Free USA shipping on orders over $75. This free shipping offer may not be combined with any other discounts or promotions.

Shipping Methods & Delivery Times:

Standard: 2–8 business days (USPS Ground)

Expedited: 1–3 business days (USPS Priority)

Express: Overnight to 2 days (USPS Priority Mail Express or UPS Next Day Air Saver)

We cannot guarantee on-time delivery due to weather, holidays, or shipping carrier delays.

International Shipping: Costs and delivery times vary by destination.

Order Notifications: To receive notifications on the status of your order, please provide your email and/or phone number.

For assistance, contact [email protected].

For more information about shipping policies, click here.

Thank you for your order!

We appreciate your business at New England Shaving Company, and we strive to ensure your satisfaction with our products. Please review our returns and refund policy carefully to understand your rights and responsibilities.

Returns are accepted within 30 days of delivery.

Items must be unused, in original condition, with all packaging and seals intact.

For hygiene and safety reasons, straight razors (all), manicure, pedicure and grooming tools, opened blades, opened creams/soaps/lotions/liquids, used brushes/combs, opened gift sets/kits, and partially used blade sampler packs are non‑returnable.

For change‑of‑mind returns, shipping fees both ways are non‑refundable, and any prepaid return label cost will be deducted from your refund.

For damaged, defective, or incorrect items, contact us within 3 business days and we will make it right

Refunds are only issued if returned items meet our return criteria and confirmed condition.